Skip to main content

Paralegal Gambler Sentenced to 16 Months for Stealing $600k

By June 23, 2008Business

Just the kind of news we don’t want to hear.  A judge sentenced a paralegal to 16 months in prison for embezzling more than $600,000 from a West Hartford law firm, the New York Lawyer reported today.

Karen Davis-Jenkins was found guilty of taking more than $600,000 from the Law Offices of Jefferson D. Jelly from 1997 until May 2005. The law firm is a sole proprietorship and employs up to five attorneys.

Davis-Jennings worked primarily on personal injury cases, handled financial books and was in charge of payroll and paying bills. She was even asked her to handle some of Jelly’s personal finances related to his mother, who suffered from dementia and lived in an assisted living facility.

Davis-Jennings, who resides in Bloomfield, began gambling regularly in 1998 at Mohegan Sun casino and began writing checks from the law office’s checking account, over which she was given signatory authority, to cover mortgage and personal credit card bills totaling $265,118. She also used a debit card that had been issued in the names of Jelly and his mother to cover personal bills totaling $243,383.

Compounding the fraud, Davis-Jenning signed Jelly’s mother’s signature on $82,385 worth of checks. As an added "bonus", Davis-Jennings falsely represented that she worked overtime and gave herself an extra $96,788.

As if that’s not enough, the New York Law Journal found an expert willing to claim that this case represents a surge in embezzlement in law firms that may be due to hard economic times.

Tammy Hailey, executive director for NALP, the Association for Legal Career Professionals, states that lawyers are better off handling finances themselves. Lawyers also should not ask paralegals to handle finances if that’s really not their expertise, she claims. And, further, she says, lawyers need to watch ethical boundaries such as Davis-Jennings’s handling of her boss’s mother’s finances.

The expert recommends that lawyers should get better employee dishonesty insurance policies. He said most firms that call him report suspected employee financial malfeasance and lack proper insurance coverage.  I’m telling you, one rotten apple……   

Close Menu
Estrin Legal Staffing
Estrin Legal Staffing
42 Google reviews
Linda Gutierrez
Linda Gutierrez
April 20, 2022.
I had the pleasure of working with Madeline and Brett they were quick to respond and get me situated with an amazing opportunity.
Brittany Toth
Brittany Toth
March 31, 2022.
I really enjoy working with this company. I’ve been working directly with Brett and he’s awesome. Super responsive and works hard to find something for you. He also doesn’t give up on you so if something ends up not working out he’ll get right back to trying to find you something. I’ve really felt supported every step of the way and recommend Estrin Legal Staffing 100%.
Audrey P.
Audrey P.
March 30, 2022.
My last two hires (different positions) were from Estrin! I am thrilled to work with them!
Rana Hill
Rana Hill
March 21, 2022.
I can't say enough good things about this staffing company, and in particular Madeline Weissman. She was more thorough and organized than any other recruiter I have worked with in the past. She spelled out everything to be successful during the interview process to make it super easy to be a successful candidate. Do not hesitate to reach out to them (specifically to Madeline!) or to apply for any openings Estrin posts. Thank you Madeline for being so on top of everything!!
Laurie Gondreau
Laurie Gondreau
March 19, 2022.
Madeline Weissman was an excellent recruiter for me and worked diligently, quickly and effectively to hook me up with a great law firm. I'm overjoyed to have found her and grateful for the hard work and help she provided to me.
Anush M.
Anush M.
March 18, 2022.
Estrin Legal Staffing is the best in the business - they are professional, provide necessary guidance, encouragement and invaluable advice. Their candidate and employer match up is top notch and delivers successful results. Maggie was a pleasure to work with - amazing personality, super responsive and diligent.
Esmeralda Weinstein
Esmeralda Weinstein
March 8, 2022.
I worked with Madeline and she was amazing! She’s about business and I love that. She helped me get an interview where I wanted to work for. She is fast at responding and let’s you know every update she has on her end until we know if we got the position or not. Thank you so much!!
Selene Vega
Selene Vega
March 7, 2022.
Maddie is awesome! She is so supportive and professional. I am so HAPPY to be working with her. I know I am in good hands with Maddie on my side. I cannot stress enough how thankful I am for her and Estrin Legal Staffing.
Ashley Williams
Ashley Williams
March 7, 2022.
Stacey is the absolute best! She is very diligent and hardworking & strives for the best results & I appreciate everything she’s done to help me in my career! 🤎🤎